Browse: Home / National Health Insurance will devastate private healthcare – IRR

Menu

Skip to content
Warning: getimagesize(): http:// wrapper is disabled in the server configuration by allow_url_fopen=0 in /usr/www/users/inengvbxmm/wp-content/themes/fearless/includes/template-tags.php on line 337 Warning: getimagesize(https://ineng.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2014/12/Public-Policy-entrepreneurs-1.jpg): failed to open stream: no suitable wrapper could be found in /usr/www/users/inengvbxmm/wp-content/themes/fearless/includes/template-tags.php on line 337
Header image

Ineng Warning: getimagesize(): http:// wrapper is disabled in the server configuration by allow_url_fopen=0 in /usr/www/users/inengvbxmm/wp-content/themes/fearless/includes/template-tags.php on line 365 Warning: getimagesize(https://ineng.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2017/05/Ineng-LOGO-PNG-2017-05-29.png): failed to open stream: no suitable wrapper could be found in /usr/www/users/inengvbxmm/wp-content/themes/fearless/includes/template-tags.php on line 365 Logo

Independent Entrepreneurship Group

Menu

Skip to content
  • News
  • Articles
  • Events
  • Issues
    • Energy
    • Business Licensing Bill
    • Economic Freedom
    • Compliance and Ease of Doing Business
    • Consumer Choice
    • Global Investment and Expansion
    • One Stop Shops
    • Asset Ownership
    • Property Rights
    • Social Safety Net
    • Visa-Free Travel in Africa
    • Immigration and Visa Policies
    • End Government Bailouts of SAA
  • Data
  • About Ineng
    • About Ineng
    • Speakers
    • Contact Us
      • Product Page
    • Join Mailing List
Durban, South Africa

National Health Insurance will devastate private healthcare – IRR

Posted by admin on 22 Aug 2018 in News | 453 Views | Leave a response

‘What’s Wrong with the Golden Promise of the NHI?’ – the latest report from the Institute of Race Relations (IRR) – is a detailed critique of the government’s proposed National Health Insurance system. 

It argues that while South Africa’s deeply deficient public health service is in desperate need of reform, the ‘main purpose of the National Health Insurance (NHI) is not to improve health services but rather to drive the private sector out of the healthcare sphere’.

The National Health Insurance system ‘will help achieve this by putting an end to the medical schemes that primarily fund private medicine and are essential to its survival’, writes author of the report, IRR Head of Policy Research Dr Anthea Jeffery.

Durban, South Africa. National Health Insurance

How National Health Insurance will affect South Africa’s Citizens

At risk – along with the healthcare of the country’s 58 million citizens – is South Africa’s ‘world-class system of private healthcare, to which some 30% of its population on average, or roughly 17 million people, have access through their medical schemes, health insurance policies, or out-of-pocket payments’.

The report notes that South Africa’s 82 medical schemes ‘are vital in providing access to private healthcare’ to 9.5 million people (up from 6.9 million in 1997), of whom 48% are now black, while 11% are so-called ‘coloureds’, seven percent are Indian and the remaining 34% are white.
‘Despite this major shift, the government plans to use the NHI to put an end to almost all medical schemes’, primarily because of its ideological hostility to the ‘profit’ motive in private healthcare.
The government’s determination to press ahead with a new, vast bureaucracy – likely to cost an unsustainable R500bn at its start and possibly going as high as R1 trillion – ‘makes no attempt’ to remedy profound defects in the public health system. 

Writes Jeffery: ‘South Africa currently spends four percent of gross domestic product (GDP) on public healthcare, which is more than many other emerging economies can manage. But, despite the best efforts of many dedicated professionals working in the sector, the country gets little “bang” for its substantial “buck”. Instead, public healthcare is plagued by poor management, gross inefficiency, persistent wastefulness, and often corrupt spending.

‘The upshot is that 85% of public clinics and hospitals cannot comply with basic norms and standards, even on such essentials as hygiene and the availability of medicines. Cases of medical negligence – often involving botched operations or brain damage to newborn infants – have increased to the point where claims for compensation total R56bn. This is more than a quarter (27%) of the entire R201bn budget for public healthcare in 2018/19.’

Instead, the National Health Insurance system ‘assumes that throwing more resources at the public sector will provide a cure-all, whereas poor skills, cadre deployment, and a crippling lack of accountability lie at the heart of the malaise and will have to be overcome’.

By contrast, the NHI will likely undermine the potential for improvements. ‘South Africa is already short of nurses, doctors, specialists, and other health providers, but the NHI offers no credible means of increasing their supply. On the contrary, the pool of available health providers and facilities is likely to shrink once the NHI takes effect.

‘This is firstly because only 15% of public clinics and public hospitals currently do well enough on basic norms and standards to qualify for National Health Insurance participation. The remaining 85% … fail to maintain proper standards of hygiene and the like and will be barred from taking part. In addition, many private specialists, doctors, and other health providers with scarce skills might decide to emigrate, rather than subject themselves to NHI controls over their fees and treatment decisions.’
The report advances proposals for a successful healthcare system available to all. 

‘Universal health coverage is already available, mostly for no charge, through the country’s public clinics and hospitals. To function better, these need merit-based appointments, strict accountability for poor performance, and effective action against corruption and wasteful spending. Public-private partnerships would also help improve their operation.

‘The burden on the public system should also be reduced by increasing access to private healthcare. Low-cost medical schemes and primary health insurance policies should be allowed, while poor households should be helped to join these schemes or buy these policies through tax-funded health vouchers. 

‘To help spread risks, medical scheme membership and/or health insurance cover should be mandatory for all employees, with premiums for lower-paid employees buttressed by employer contributions for which businesses would garner tax credits. Medical schemes and health insurers would then have to compete for the custom of South Africans, which would encourage innovation and help to hold down costs.’

But none of these solutions will emerge through NHI. The report warns that ‘by the time people realise that the National Health Insurance cannot deliver on its golden promises, the private healthcare system will effectively have been destroyed. South Africans will then be left with nothing but a failing state monopoly on which to rely’.

Read the full report here <https://irr.org.za/reports/occasional-reports/whats-wrong-with-the-golden-promise-of-nhi>.

Posted in News | Tagged health, healthcare, Institute of Race Relations, medical aid, National Health Insurance, NHI, South Africa

Related Posts

Frans Cronje talks about what South Africa will be like in 2030 in JohannesburgWhat will South Africa be like in 2030?→

IRR report on the National Health Insurance scheme in South AfricaRead the IRR’s Report on the National Health Insurance scheme→

Union Buildings, Pretoria. Reasons not to vote for the ANC in the 2019 Election.Cyril Ramaphosa announces Cabinet Reshuffle→

International Flights from South Africa. Direct International Flights from JohannesburgInternational Flights from South Africa’s major airports: Johannesburg, Cape Town and Durban→

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Ineng on Facebook

Popular Posts

  • A photo of the South African parliament. Where South African Government Policies are made.

    South African Government Policies

    35742 views / Posted 21 Jul 2015
  • List of SADC Countries in 2018

    13208 views / Posted 8 Oct 2018
  • Nelson Mandela Bridge Johannesburg

    State of Entrepreneurship in South Africa

    11289 views / Posted 24 Dec 2015
  • Free Speech at South African Universities

    Free Speech at South African Universities

    9377 views / Posted 20 Dec 2018
  • Missing image

    The Future of South Africa

    8441 views / Posted 27 Jun 2018
  • A photo of an A380 aeroplane. Goes with an article about Visa Free Countries for South African travellers.

    Visa Free Countries for South Africans

    8395 views / Posted 6 Jul 2018
  • A map showing the provinces of South Africa by Gross Domestic Product per capita

    South African Provinces by GDP per capita

    5786 views / Posted 3 May 2018
  • List of SADC countries by GDP

    List of SADC Countries by GDP

    5761 views / Posted 24 Aug 2018
  • independent western cape

    Western Cape Independence

    4117 views / Posted 24 Jul 2018
  • Unemployment in South Africa. Many people are out of work and jobless.

    Devastating calamity of South African labour legislation

    3670 views / Posted 20 Oct 2014
  • List of SADC countries by population

    List of SADC Countries by Population

    2991 views / Posted 7 Sep 2018
  • Economic Freedom in South Africa

    Economic Freedom in South Africa

    2949 views / Posted 23 Dec 2015
  • A photo of Johannesburg council chamber - South African Public Policy in 2018

    South African Public Policy in 2018

    2859 views / Posted 30 Jun 2018
  • A photo of a small shop in South Africa

    The new Expropriation Bill: a Threat to Small Businesses?

    2749 views / Posted 11 May 2015
  • A map made using Google Data Studio showing the level of Economic Freedom among SADC countries in 2018

    Economic Freedom among SADC countries in 2018

    2732 views / Posted 1 May 2018

Recent Posts

  • South African flag - South Africa

    Who will win the 2019 Elections in South Africa? IRR releases surprising new poll results

    30 Apr 2019 / admin
  • A group of protesting people against threats facing South Africa

    Facts about South African voters ahead of the 2019 Election

    14 Apr 2019 / admin
  • Capitalist Party of South Africa

    A Guide to the Capitalist Party of South Africa (ZACP)

    20 Mar 2019 / admin
  • Unathi Kwaza

    Unathi Kwaza key member of new Political Party – the Capitalist Party of South Africa

    18 Mar 2019 / admin
  • Big Daddy Liberty interviews South African Voters

    Big Daddy Liberty interviews ANC, DA, EFF Supporters ahead of the 2019 Election

    8 Mar 2019 / admin
  • How to Stop Expropriation without Compensation

    How to Stop Expropriation Without Compensation

    8 Feb 2019 / admin
  • Frans Cronje talks about what South Africa will be like in 2030 in Johannesburg

    What will South Africa be like in 2030?

    17 Jan 2019 / admin
  • Buildings in Sandton, Johannesburg. Most Developed Countries in Africa.

    Top 10 Most Developed African Countries

    16 Jan 2019 / admin
  • Free Speech at South African Universities

    Free Speech at South African Universities

    20 Dec 2018 / admin
  • IRR report on the National Health Insurance scheme in South Africa

    Read the IRR’s Report on the National Health Insurance scheme

    13 Dec 2018 / admin
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
 

Recent posts

  • South African flag - South Africa

    Who will win the 2019 Elections in South Africa? IRR releases surprising new poll results

    30 Apr 2019 / admin
  • A group of protesting people against threats facing South Africa

    Facts about South African voters ahead of the 2019 Election

    14 Apr 2019 / admin
 
 
 

©2013 - 2019 Ineng

Menu

Google+